Executive Functions: Formative Versus Reflective Measurement

Michael T. Willoughby, Dr. Steven John Holochwost, Zane E. Blanton, Clancy B. Blair


Taylor & Francis

Measurement: Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives, Vol 12(3), Jul, 2014. pp.69-95. Publisher: Taylor & Francis 


The primary objective of this article was to critically evaluate the routine use of confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) for representing an individual’s performance across a battery of executive function tasks. A conceptual review and statistical reanalysis of N = 10 studies that used CFA methods of EF tasks was undertaken. Despite evidence of excellent global model fit for CFA models, studies were uniformly characterized by weak correlations among EF tasks and weak to moderate levels of maximal reliability of latent EF constructs. Vanishing tetrad tests raised the possibility that individual tasks may be better conceptualized as causal rather than as effect indicators of the latent construct of EF. The use of CFA methods with EF tasks that are weakly correlated results in latent variables that have poor to modest maximal reliability. This undermines efforts to use latent variables of EF as predictors or outcomes in empirical studies and has implications for theory development. Greater attention to and resolution of the discrepancies between conceptual definitions and statistical approaches that are used to model EF has implications for the long-term value of using EF in research and clinical settings. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2014 APA, all rights reserved)

Access the publication.


Recent Publications

Book: The Routledge Companion to Music and Human Rights


The Routledge Companion to Music and Human Rights is a collection of case studies spanning a wide range of concerns about music and human rights in response to intensifying >>

Making Music, Promoting Development: The Power of Practice


A chapter by Dennie Palmer Wolf, Steven Holochwost, and Judith Hill Bose in the new volume, Music Learning As Youth Development. Music Learning as Youth Development explores how music education programs >>

Save the Arts and Serve All the People

Joseph H. Kluger, Gary P. Steuer

May 16, 2020


Save the arts and serve all the people, restore OACCE and PCF budgets, Part 2 Although we understand the City of Philadelphia faces financial challenges from the coronavirus >>